MONUMETRIC Video mmt-volt

Collapse

Steel Beams with Wood Nailers

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Kate
    Member
    • September 4, 2014
    • 64
    • Ann Arbor, MI

    Steel Beams with Wood Nailers

    Howdy everyone,

    I'm developing our structural framing families. I'd like to modify our WF and HSS steel beams to allow the modelling of wood nailers on their tops and bottoms.

    My initial idea was to do this without creating duplicate beam families by controlling the nailer visibility with an instance boolean, so where needed the user could enable the nailer and have it appear. The nailer dimensions will also be instance parameters to allow maximum flexibility.

    I created the nailer extrusion without an issue, but it is affecting the behavior of the beam in the model in a way I hadn't expected.

    By default Revit families have framing modeled centered on the reference plane, but when you place beams in models the default z justification is 'top', so beams are shown with their top of steel at the level of the reference plane. (See this link for a bit further explanation / screencast example: https://forums.autodesk.com/t5/revit-architecture-forum/beam-family-help/td-p/5788748)

    Modelling the nailer causes the top of the nailer to be at the level of the reference plane in the project environment, which I don't want. I'd like the top of steel to be at the level of the reference plane - that is, for the beam to act like it doesn't have a nailer on top.

    Is there a way to get the desired behavior without modifying the default z-justification value? Essentially, to 'tell' Revit where the real 'top' of the member is.

    My scheme if that isn't possible is to modify the framing families such that the origin is at the reference level, and then change my z-justification in the project template so that it is set to origin by default, allowing it to work with my custom beam families.
    Attached Files
  • mendler
    Member
    • August 7, 2014
    • 30

    #2
    Originally posted by Kate
    Howdy everyone,

    I'm developing our structural framing families. I'd like to modify our WF and HSS steel beams to allow the modelling of wood nailers on their tops and bottoms.

    My initial idea was to do this without creating duplicate beam families by controlling the nailer visibility with an instance boolean, so where needed the user could enable the nailer and have it appear. The nailer dimensions will also be instance parameters to allow maximum flexibility.

    I created the nailer extrusion without an issue, but it is affecting the behavior of the beam in the model in a way I hadn't expected.

    By default Revit families have framing modeled centered on the reference plane, but when you place beams in models the default z justification is 'top', so beams are shown with their top of steel at the level of the reference plane. (See this link for a bit further explanation / screencast example: https://forums.autodesk.com/t5/revit-architecture-forum/beam-family-help/td-p/5788748)

    Modelling the nailer causes the top of the nailer to be at the level of the reference plane in the project environment, which I don't want. I'd like the top of steel to be at the level of the reference plane - that is, for the beam to act like it doesn't have a nailer on top.

    Is there a way to get the desired behavior without modifying the default z-justification value? Essentially, to 'tell' Revit where the real 'top' of the member is.

    My scheme if that isn't possible is to modify the framing families such that the origin is at the reference level, and then change my z-justification in the project template so that it is set to origin by default, allowing it to work with my custom beam families.


    Make it a nested family. I solved it this way before

    Comment

    • Kate
      Member
      • September 4, 2014
      • 64
      • Ann Arbor, MI

      #3
      Thanks for the suggestion mendler.

      I tried this and it solved part of my issue - when I have the 'nailer' parameter turned off, the top of the beam is at the correct elevation (not being pushed down like it was before).

      However, when I turn the nailer parameter on, it still pushes the beam down by the thickness of the nailer, rather than projecting the nailer above the top of steel. I've attached my modified family with the nested nailer if you'd like to take a look.

      Attached Files

      Comment

      Related Topics

      Collapse

      Working...