Is there a way to link loads from one linked model to another? Our MEP engineers are having issues trying to deal with content in the core and shell and how it tie into it in the Tenant Finish model. Any workflow suggestions welcome.
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Core and Shell Model with Separate Tenant Finish Models
Collapse
X
-
Core and Shell Model with Separate Tenant Finish Models
Scott D. Brown, AIA | Senior Project Manager | Beck GroupTags: None
-
I think joseph peel mentioned in a thread a while back that you can create a family that you can copy monitor (say like a VAV box) that would hold all of the information between the tenant and core models and allow it to be transferred between links. I've never done it though, so I can't comment on how well it works.
Comment
-
{Appears in cloud of smoke}You summoned me?
Yes, it works but try to keep it simple.
Make a small shared Elec/Mech Equipment block and put it in the families you want to link. Make types for as much of the data as possible (Type data gets copied instance doesnt). You can set the link object in your other families with a Family Type/Label parameter.
Works well if you can make it very modular and consistent, like electrical/thermal power in 5 fixed steps that you can select per family type rather than a specific load for every object.
If you want to transfer instance data you need to use dynamo. Get all the copy monitored objects in both models, match the coordinates to know which objects are paired, copy the instance data from the linked object to the current model.
Its something I am using on a project where we have equipment in furniture (Arch models the furniture with the blocks in, we copy monitor the blocks) but I want to develop it further for pipe connections between models or connections into large equipment like AHUs. Then it would be possible to make separate models for each discipline (HVAC, Elec, Plumbing, etc..) so that each engineer/modeller can have their own lightweight model and loacations+loads still get communicated between models.
My work here is done {Disappears with a flash}Last edited by josephpeel; May 16, 2019, 10:33 AM."One must imagine Sisyphus happy." Albert Camus - "The innovator has for enemies all those who have done well under the old conditions, and lukewarm defenders in those who may do well under the new." Nicolo Machiavelli -"Things that are too complex are not useful, Things that are useful are simple." Mikhail Kalashnikov
Comment
-
I had to read that post a few times but I think I get it, you're talking about using that small block family to 'produce' the thermal power load that the Space is then reporting in the Actual Power Load parameter, right? Did you give that family to your Architect and ask him to add it to his furniture families?
I like this idea. I've been manually typing the wattage into the Spaces and that's been working fine, but it would be great to have that information be part of the Furniture families. I think I may do this, but place small hidden families in my MEP model. That way I can control their heat output and placement. I'd have to manually coordinate them with the arch model but I'm okay with that. I need to leave myself something to do.
I'm starting a project right now and it's still in that initial Space/Zoning/Load Calculation phase. I think I'll set this up and try it out! At this point I do all of my data entry work in Revit and then gbxml out to Carrier HAP to run the actual load calc.
So how do you handle lighting power/heat gain? We just apply a standard 1.1 w/sf (11.88 w/m2) to all of our spaces. Are you using the actual wattage from your lighting fixture families?
Comment
-
Just a quick update, I created a little "block" family of my own and created types for various heat generating devices: workstations, copiers, refrigerators, etc, and then copied them around my model. Worked like a charm, once I turned on Space Calculations in the Electrical Settings and set the electrical connectors space calculation to "power."
I really like this approach because I can schedule this new family and break the schedule down by Space. I also made a "Type Schedule" for these objects so I can centrally control the wattage of each item and have the change propogate across the whole model. Then when it's all set I can gbxml it over to my load calc program!
Thanks for yet another great idea, Joseph!
Comment
Related Topics
Collapse
-
So I thought I'd just start a discussion on a topic I've been thinking about recently
Our current workflow is to link the MECH model to...-
Channel: MEP - General
February 8, 2018, 03:03 AM -
-
Got another issue hopefully you guys can help me out with.
Our electrical engineer is copy/monitoring over all of our mechanical equipment...-
Channel: MEP - General
September 23, 2014, 01:28 PM -
-
Hey guys, how are you doing?
So, I've been working with Revit MEP for a while and so far I've been using different templates to coordinate...-
Channel: MEP - General
December 4, 2016, 01:17 PM -
-
Hello All =)
I am trying to link a equipment Revit model into my architectural Revit model. A few issues are arising. First, the equip model...July 10, 2013, 04:53 PM -
Our current project includes 8 different models linked into the central model. Most things seem to be working fine, however, my question is,....does the...July 25, 2013, 04:20 PM
Comment