Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Post of the Month [New forum functionality]

Collapse
X
Collapse
 
  • Page of 3
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
Previous 1 2 3 template Next
    #1

    Post of the Month [New forum functionality]

    The "automated" POTM functionality is now enabled for public Beta testing.

    Please use this thread for feedback :beer:

    What determines the Post of the Month?
    • POTM is based on a simple nomination system. The 25 posts with the most nominations in a month’s time are automatically generated into a list of top nominees, and there will be a final Poll with the top 10 from that list. All registered members are then able to vote for their favorite choice amongst the ten final posts.
    • Any post on the forum is eligible for the Post of the Month (POTM) award. Any registered member is eligible to nominate a post for Modification of the Month.


    Nomination Guidelines:
    • Every post has a small button on the upper right corner titled: 'Nominate for Post of the Month' that allows you to nominate that post.
    • Members are allowed to nominate as many posts every month as they wish.
    • All decisions are final, and members cannot change their decision once they have nominated a post.
    • Once a post has been nominated, it will be become visible to all registered members, that the post has been nominated by at least one other member already.
    • A live list of current and previous month/year nominations is available here (Can also be found from the "Quick Links" pull down at the top navigation bar)
    • It´s not allowed, nor is it possible to nominate own posts.
    • When a post is nominated, the poster is awarded with 2 reputation points. (Regular reputation is 10 points)


    Nomination Dates and Deadlines:
    • The 'Nominate for Post of the Month' button is visible for 15 days after the post is made. After that period, it´s no longer possible to nominate the post.
    • The 15 day limit is to ensure that posts from previous months are not nominated again.
    • The 15 day limit is also to ensure equal exposure to all posts, and giving a post made at the end of a month a fair chance against a post from the beginning of a month.


    Poll Voting Guidelines:
    • Voting is ultimately up to the voters. Be sure to take a close look at all the nominees and evaluate the value of each nominated post. Judgment is based on one’s personal opinions – no one else’s.
    • Each member can only vote for one nominee.
    • Voting for own posts are allowed and possible, but not considered fair game.
    • All posts awarded as POTM will get listed in this thread.


    Poll Voting Dates and Deadlines:
    • Monthly polls are generated the 15th day of the following month. Nominations will still be valid for that month until the poll is generated.
    • The Poll will be open for 7 days, giving the members a week to cast their votes.
    • The winner of the POTM award will be announced on the 22nd.
    Attached Files
    Klaus Munkholm
    "Do. Or do not. There is no try."
    Tags: None
    #2
    Forgot to mention that the 15 day limit is currently a bit longer, to allow nominations on all posts in March :beer:
    Klaus Munkholm
    "Do. Or do not. There is no try."

    Comment

      #3
      Nice addition awarding 2 rep ponts for a nomination. Very cool idea.
      Dan

      Comment

        #4
        FYI
        The 2 points of Rep is causing some problems I think. If you nominate a post, they then are unable to give real rep for that same post. I dont know if this works vice a versa thouhg. I would think that if you gave rep points that you wouldnt be able to nominate the same post for POTM.
        -Alex Cunningham

        Comment

          #5
          Hmmm... you might be on to something Alex! Have not tested this yet... but will look into it :beer:
          Klaus Munkholm
          "Do. Or do not. There is no try."

          Comment

            #6
            Originally posted by Munkholm View Post
            Hmmm... you might be on to something Alex! Have not tested this yet... but will look into it :beer:
            C'mon Munk, if you can't think of every problem before implementing it, what are we paying you for?? lol
            Dan

            Comment

              #7
              :hide: Good point
              Klaus Munkholm
              "Do. Or do not. There is no try."

              Comment

                #8
                Just checked the live list of nominated posts, and while I do appreciate that some of you appreciate this new functionality, the functionality has been turned off in this sub forum, and in the out there forum.

                POTM awards should be Revit related, not vB related :beer:
                Klaus Munkholm
                "Do. Or do not. There is no try."

                Comment

                  #9
                  Originally posted by Alex Cunningham View Post
                  FYI
                  The 2 points of Rep is causing some problems I think. If you nominate a post, they then are unable to give real rep for that same post. I dont know if this works vice a versa thouhg. I would think that if you gave rep points that you wouldnt be able to nominate the same post for POTM.
                  Just did an extensive test on this, and supposedly there´s no problems with the POTM functionality in this regard... :beer:

                  But let me know if you experience any trouble with this...
                  Klaus Munkholm
                  "Do. Or do not. There is no try."

                  Comment

                    #10
                    I am still not able to nominate posts that I have given rep points on, or give rep points to posts that I have nominated. It tells me that I cant give rep points to posts I have already given rep too.
                    -Alex Cunningham

                    Comment

                    Previous 1 2 3 template Next

                    Related Topics

                    Collapse
                    • The Best Posts of the Month
                      Today is the last day of the month of January. This is the first issue of The Best Posts of the Month. This is an idea that we start today and hope to...
                      January 31, 2011, 03:42 PM
                    • The Best Posts of the Month of February 2011. Please nominate 3
                      The Best Posts of the Month

                      Yesterday was the last day of February 2010. This is a new issue of The Best Posts of the Month. This is an...
                      March 1, 2011, 04:38 AM
                    • Post of The Month - "Automatic" nominations
                      We are very close to introducing a new forum function, to "automate" the nomination process for Post of The Month (POTM).

                      Here´s...
                      March 24, 2011, 10:20 PM
                    • Please Vote for the 3 Best Posts of the Month of February 2011
                      From this list of the 10 most nominated posts, please vote for 3 posts, that in your opinion, should be elected as The Best 3 Posts of the Month of February...
                      Post # 15 in "Casework" by Aaron Maller (Twiceroadsfool)
                      17.24%
                      5
                      Post # 1 in "Thinking of making some add ons to sell...feedback?" by Jeffrey McGrew
                      3.45%
                      1
                      Post # 69 in "Challenge: A parametric corner piece" by Munkholm
                      17.24%
                      5
                      Post # 85 in "Challenge: A parametric corner piece" by Munkholm
                      10.34%
                      3
                      Post # 1 in "Revit Sharing Content - Common RFO Style-Guide" by Munkholm
                      17.24%
                      5
                      Post # 1 in "More Shortcut Key Magic" by Mark B.
                      17.24%
                      5
                      Post # 16 in "New API Utility" by Feio
                      0.00%
                      0
                      Post # 2 in "Calling all journal gurus" by Scott B (Factory worker)
                      6.90%
                      2
                      Post # 2 in "Subscriptions?" by Aaron MALLER (Twiceroadsfool)
                      0.00%
                      0
                      Post # 2 in "Splitting up a model?" by Alfredo Medina
                      10.34%
                      3
                      March 4, 2011, 03:37 AM
                    • The Posts of the Month
                      For those of you who had been following this activity of The Post of the Month, and who might be waiting for the announcement about opening the nomination...
                      April 1, 2011, 04:17 AM
                    Working...
                    X